CIty of St. Petersburg Florida approves $2.5 million settlement in 2025 for Heriberto Sanchez-Mayen, who claimed actions by city police officers in 2023 left him paralyzed and a double amputee.
The lawsuit, filed in federal court, alleged that Sanchez-Mayen was arrested for trespassing and transported in a police van without proper restraints. A sudden stop caused him to be thrown inside the vehicle, resulting in severe spinal injuries. Surveillance footage later showed an officer dragging an unconscious Sanchez-Mayen from the van, causing further trauma.
The St. Petersburg City Council voted unanimously to approve the settlement on April 3, 2025. Under Florida law, the city will pay $200,000 immediately, with the remaining $2.3 million contingent on legislative approval through a claims bill.
The civil lawsuit named the city and officers Sarah Gaddis and Michael Thacker as defendants, alleging false arrest, battery, and excessive force. While a federal judge dismissed claims against Gaddis, the lawsuit against Thacker moved forward on two counts: battery and excessive force.
In a notable ruling, U.S. District Judge William Jung described Thacker’s actions—particularly the removal of Sanchez-Mayen from the van—as “reckless” and “callous,” stating it would be improper even by basic first aid standards.
City Attorney Joseph Patner emphasized the settlement resolved a single count of negligence, not intentional misconduct. “This was an accident,” he said. “Ultimately, all intentional allegations were dropped.”
Attorneys for Sanchez-Mayen said the settlement reflects the city’s acknowledgment of the serious injuries sustained. “This is a tragic and avoidable situation,” said attorney Tom Scolaro. Sanchez-Mayen, who was homeless at the time of his arrest, is now recovering in a Pennsylvania rehabilitation facility near his sister. The funds will be placed in a trust to assist with long-term care not covered by Medicaid.
The case has also raised concerns about detainee safety during transport. Although patrol vehicles are equipped with seatbelts, the department’s transport vans are not. Despite the incident, the St. Petersburg Police Department has no plans to revise its policy.
Legal experts say the case could impact future discussions around law enforcement liability, detainee rights, and municipal responsibility in excessive force claims.
If you or a loved one have suffered injuries due to police misconduct or negligence, our firm is here to help. Contact us for a confidential consultation.
Source: Tampa Bay Times
